Someone posted this on the motorcycle forum I go to and I never heard this before:
“What’s cool is the Blue Angel pilots don’t wear G suits! All other Navy pilots do! These guys gotta be in excellent shape to pull 7 G’s without a suit!”
The Blue Angels are restricted to four G’s max. The Thunderbirds are not under any restrictions because they wear G suits.
There have been several accidents where a Blue Angel pilot pulled so many G forces he grayed or blacked out and lost control.
Even with a G suit, at six G’s I would start to fade out. At seven G’s I would start to gray out and at eight G’s I would black out. Pilots could take more because of their conditioning.
According to a program on The Military Channel, they don’t wear G-Suits because of the danger of sudden inflation causing inadvertent stick motion while in close formation. Doesn’t the F-16 have the non-moving pressure-sesnsitive stick? Maybe that’s the difference, but I’m only guessing.
The stick in the F-16 does move… just not very much
If you are pulling G’s the G-suit will always be inflating/deflating, and if you have ever flown an airplane with a stick your forearm goes right where the G-suit is. With the precision those guys are flying there would be no way that a G-suit could not get in the way or be dangerous. Also, saying the Blues are restricted to 4 G’s is absolutely false, look at videos of their routine, they are pulling MUCH more than 4 G’s.
The only way a G suit could inflate is under positive G forces. The more G forces, the more the inflation. The Blue Angles say they don’t wear G suits is because it doesn’t look professional with their colored flight suits. They also say their pilots are so well trained and conditioned they don’t need them. As a result they can pull only 4 G’s sustained with five or six G’s for short limited periods. At no time are they allowed to exceed six G’s. Without a G suit, no matter how well trained or conditioned a pilot is, he would soon black out at sustained 6 G’s.
The Thunderbirds require their crews to wear G suits for safety reasons. Flying over large crowds, they don’t want to take the chance of a pilot pulling too many G forces to gray or black out. Because of wearing G suits, they can put the F-16 through very high G turns, pullups and dives. That is something the Blues can’t do because of limited restrictions.
G-suits are designed with air bladders (pockets) that inflate and deflate to keep a pilot’s blood from pooling in the pilots’ legs while executing sharp, unpredicted combat maneuvers.
Unlike combat flying the Blue Angels demonstration pilots know the maneuvers they will fly prior to execution, each pilot knows when one will be pulling gravitational forces. Knowing and anticipating the changes in gravitational forces allows the Blue Angels demonstration pilots to combat the G-forces with muscle contractions.
In addition, the Boeing F/A-18’s control stick is mounted so it is centered between the pilot’s legs. The Blue Angels have a spring, with 35 pounds of pressure, installed on the control stick that gives the pilot a “false feel,” allowing the pilot minimal room for uncommanded movement. The pilots rest their right arms on their thighs for support and stability while flying. The G-suits’ inflating and deflating air bladders would interrupt this support and stability, causing uncommanded aircraft movement. Overall G-suits would detrimentally impact flight safety.
I disagree. I have seen both teams multiple times and I personally think the T-birds fly a little tighter than the Blues. Aviators and not pilots huh? [:-^]
I like what my wife’s uncle says as he was a career Air Force man, “That is not a landing on a carrier, that is just a controlled crash!” [(-D]
The Navy pilots who fly me around in Navy Vipers seem to manage.
But, yes, we wear G-suits.
And from my perspective of having time in Hornets too, the G-suit gets big enough, rapidly enough, that it DOES affect one’s grip (well, at least mine) on the stick. I know I for one would not want to try those maneuvers with a big air bag trying to push my hand off the stick. As correctly noted above, the Vipers stick being located on the side console, well away from the legs, makes this not an issue.
The officially stated reason they don’t wear G-suits is because it would interfere with the precise inputs they make while flying their routines…period. And yes they do exceed 4 G’s…All military pilots are trained to handle G’s using muscle control and breathing—and practice. Oxygen is only really needed above 10,000ft…
Are we ready to turn this into a pissing contest to see which team is better? Because I have a strong argument for saying NEITHER the Blues or The TBirds are the best. [oX)]
It’s correct, no g-suits for the Blue Angles because they cause very small movements that are not tolerable during their performances.
I’ve no vested interest in backing either aerobatic demonstration team, Air Force or Navy, but I’ve seen both over a hundred times and the Blue Angles are more dynamic and bold.
I’ve been thrilled by the Thunderbirds. But I’ve been thrilled AND SCARED OUT OF MY MIND at Blue Angles performances.
Hmm… maybe I should have my G-suit looked at, because I don’t find the movements to be that small at all! [:D] When it’s fully inflated, it’s a pretty good sized bladder of air - and if I’m the one with the controls at the time, it’s inconveniently between my hand and the thigh I’m trying to rest it on. When the guy up front is driving, he doesn’t like it because my legs are big to begin with and when my G-suit inflates, it sort of limits his roll authority!! Fortunately for everyone most of my hours these days come in our Vipers.
More amusingly, there’s been a couple folks over the few years I’ve been here who have, in the course of their anti-G straining let their inflated leg trip the radio switch on the Hornet’s throttle… which can make for an amusing sequence of grunting and whatnot coming out on the radio in the middle of a fight.
First of all, I love the Blues and Tbirds as much as anyone. I’ve grown up seeing them. I haven’t missed a Miramar airshow in 21 years…yet for the first time last year, the Blues were NOT there, the Tbirds were. Also, the Blues flew a better show with the A-4.
Having said that… Pound for pound, the best I’ve seen are the Frecce Tricolori. They fly every bit as tight as anyone else, and they do it in a 10-ship formation, not just 4 or 6. They fly manuevers impossible in an F-16 or F-18, like a full-on tailslide, and a true nose-vertex conical lomcevak. The Tbirds fly some sharp maneuvers, like crisp 4-points rolls, but they have the aid of a FBW system. The Frecce fly them nearly just as crisp, with even more points (saw a 16-point before) and without the aid of FBW. The Blues come close, and they don’t have a full FBW system either, but the Frecce are still better. The FT also some very precise formaton changes mid-maneuver, that neither the BA or the TB do. This to me shows more precise aircraft control. I’ve trained in aerobatics myself, and I tend to look more for technical proffeciency, than flashy show manuevers. Flashy is cool though, I enjoy a Calypso Pass, a Double Farvel, or Fleur De Lis as much as the next guy. But watching a pilot do a slow roll can show more about their ability that you think.
I’ve seen just about all the major teams, Snowbirds, BA, TB, Red Arrows, Patrouille de France, Patrouille Swisse, Turkish Stars, Blue Impulse, etc… And I still think, IMHO, that the Frecce Tricolori are still the best, pound for pound. The Escadrilha da Fumaca come pretty close too, but to watch the Frecce do stuff in their jets…awesome.