Nice badge, simple and to the point.
My 2 bits… historicaly speaking, Monty missed the first two years of the North Africa campaign, only coming in after a series of previous commanders had been sacked or captured, and the man that he succeeded was killed in an air crash. Rommel missed the opening stages of the Desert War and the closing stage. Patton was on the stage only for the final 6 months. But in the popular image of that part of WWII, Rommel and Montgomery, evoke the image of that campaign and are known in history for just that- The Desert Fox and First Viscount Montgomery of El Alamein.
No offense to George (or Omar, or Ike), or any of the Italian Generals, but they do not truly evoke the spirit of North Africa
I think that the badge works great.
Thanks everyone for the help. Put me down for a Tamiya SdkFz 222 Afrika Korps and maybe, depending on time, a HobbyBoss M3A1 Scout.
Thanks to all for voicing their opinion on the badge design.
For some American flavour, what I can do is replace the silhouette of the British cruiser tank with that of an American made tank that was used by the desert allies. Would this be satisfactory to all? If yes, which would you like to see there?
regards,
Jack
How about a Sherman?
It was a casual comment…
Bill, dig your Rommel;s Rod. always wanted one as a kid.
Jack, I think the badge is fine. I do like the Afrika Korps insignia though as well as the Desert Rats. Just talking to myself though.
I get it now, I was on the receiving end of the devil’s advocate stick - good one.
Eric, yes I did some considering of those two symbols. The DAK emblem - I just wasn’t sure how receptive everyone would be towards seeing a graphic swastika. I’ll see what can come up with in a few days.
regards,
Jack
Jack, there are quite a few GB badges with the swastika in them. I can understand your caution though.
I don’t really mind a swastika on the badge and I’m living in a country that was actually involved in the crimes that were commited under that symbol (and it is a pretty dark part of our history)
Tigerman,
I’d like to join this one! I gotta’ check the stash to see what would qualify…I’ll get back to you soon!
SMJmodeler
hey SMJ, long time no see - do hope you can join us on this one.
Alrighty, badge with the jeroboa and swastika:
As mentioned, I already had some thoughts on these emblems earlier, so the work was mostly getting those ideas onto the screen. The overall badge would perhaps work better if the rat image would be mirrored (ie facing left) and located on the right half portion to tie in with Monty attacking westwards. This marking though is always depicted with the jeroboa facing right.
I introduced the tank silhouettes into the logo to save space, and their facing emulates the offensive directions of the axis and allied forces (well except for the Torch landings - I’m prepared this time - lol). The elements are not all that detailed, but this will lend better when the badge is shrunk to one’s size preference.
regards,
Jack
Those look good as well Jack. I will be perfectly content to use either design once I have completed my build. I know the historical record.
“it’s only a model”
That’s neat looking, Jack.
Agreed, both are great badges. I don’t know which one I like better.
Eagle90
Looks great Jack- think I prefer the first one though.
Welcome Steve. Glad to have an another awesome build come from you.
I can’t make up my mind on the badges.
Glad to see you back Steve.
Why not got with both badges Eric. I like them both but I think the second just has the edge for me. I like the tank silhouettes.
Gents,
I need some HELP! I checked the stash last night ( and was reminded of how historically inept I am[:(DD]) Here are the kits I “think” would qualify:
35105 AFV Club-U.S. M5A1 Stuart
6404 Dragon-U.S. M4A1 DV Sherman
9037 Dragon-Sherman Firefly Ic Hybrid Hull
35244 Tamiya-U.S. M26 Armored Tank Recovery Vehicle
Can someone please let me know which one(s) (if any) qualify… and/or are definately DIS-qualified. Thanks[;)]
My [2cnts] on the badge thingy: Both are AWESOME!..I like the two badge idea, it gives us a chance to pick our fav’ and it also gives those who build TWO entries a second badge!
Early M5s saw service in North Africa, but very little, the M3 was the most common US light tank used there. I would have to go check my references to see if the M5A1 was there. The M4A1 DV is a definite yes. First introduced into combat with the Brits at El Alamein in October, and then a few weeks later with US forces in the Torch landings. The composite hull Firefly Sherman is out. Both of those versions (any Firefly, or the composite hull) did not see service and action until 1944. As for the M26 Dragon Wagon- that is a good question.
I agree with offereing both badges, let the builder have a choice.